Your HOA sent you a fine. Maybe it is $100. Maybe it is $500. Maybe it keeps growing every day because they say it is a "continuing violation."
Before you pay, ask a simple question: Is this fine even legal?
HOA fines are not unlimited. Many states set hard caps on how much your HOA can charge. And even in states without caps, your HOA has to follow specific procedures before any fine is valid. Skipping those procedures makes the fine void — regardless of the amount.
The Most Important Thing to Understand
Your HOA's fine power comes from two sources:
- State law — the rules your state legislature wrote that every HOA must follow
- Your CC&Rs — your HOA's official rulebook (CC&Rs stands for Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) that sets out the specific rules for your community
State law always wins. If your CC&Rs say the HOA can charge $500 per violation, but your state caps fines at $100, the CC&R language does not matter. The cap stands.
Fine Limits by State
Florida
Continuing violations cap: $1,000 total (unless your CC&Rs specifically authorize more)
Lien protection: Fines under $1,000 cannot become a lien on your home.
Important: If your fine notice says more than $100 per single violation, that excess is illegal under Florida Statute 720.305(2). You do not have to pay it.
California
But: Fines must be "reasonable" and listed in a published fine schedule provided to all homeowners. If your HOA never gave you a fine schedule, or if the fine is not on it, the fine may be invalid.
Lien protection: The HOA cannot start foreclosure for a debt under $1,800 or less than 12 months overdue.
Procedural protection: Any fine imposed without a properly noticed hearing under Civil Code Section 5855 is void — regardless of the amount.
Texas
Lien protection: Fines under $200 cannot become a lien on your property (Texas Property Code Section 209.010).
Procedural protection: The HOA cannot collect any fine unless it first sent a proper written notice describing the violation, the required fix, the cure period, and the fine amount — by certified mail or hand delivery.
Arizona
But: Fines must be "reasonable." Late charges on fines are capped at the greater of $15 or 10% of the unpaid fine, and only after 15 days of non-payment.
Attorney fees protection: The HOA cannot collect attorney fees related to your violation until the required written exchange process is complete under A.R.S. Section 33-1803(E).
Nevada
Nevada Revised Statutes Chapter 116 does not set a statewide fine cap. Your HOA's fine schedule governs. However, fines must be reasonable and the HOA must give you a reasonable opportunity to fix the violation before fining you.
Colorado
Colorado's Common Interest Ownership Act (C.R.S. § 38-33.3) requires your HOA to adopt and follow a written enforcement policy. If they do not have one, their fines may be challengeable. There is no statewide dollar cap, but the policy must be applied consistently.
Red flag: If your HOA is charging per-day fines that are adding up to hundreds of dollars, check whether your state caps the total. Florida caps continuing violation fines at $1,000 total. Even without a cap, your HOA must send a new notice for each fine period in most states — they cannot just let a meter run without notifying you.
Is Your Fine Over the Legal Limit?
Upload your CC&Rs to HOA Hound. We check your fine against your state's law and your community's published fine schedule. If your fine is over the legal limit, we show you exactly how to dispute it.
Scan your CC&Rs free at HOA HoundThe Hidden Ways HOA Fines Grow
Your HOA fine notice may show a base fine. But by the time they try to collect, the number could be much larger. Here is how fines grow — and what limits apply to each piece:
Daily or Weekly Continuing Violation Fines
Many HOAs charge a fine for each day or week that a violation continues. This can add up fast. But most states require the HOA to send a new notice for each fine period, or at least a notice of the continuing fine schedule. If they never told you about continuing daily fines, those amounts may not be collectible.
Late Charges
Arizona limits late charges to the greater of $15 or 10% of the unpaid fine. California requires late charges to be "reasonable." If your HOA is adding late fees that seem disproportionate, check your state's law and your CC&Rs.
Attorney Fees
Many HOAs add attorney fees to the amount you owe. This is often the biggest number on the bill. In Arizona, attorney fees cannot be collected until the required violation exchange process under A.R.S. Section 33-1803 is complete. In California, internal dispute resolution must be offered before litigation. If those steps were skipped, the attorney fee claim may be invalid.
Collection Costs
Some HOAs hire collection agencies and add their fees to your bill. Check your CC&Rs to see whether collection costs are authorized. Not every HOA's documents allow this.
What to Do If Your Fine Is Over the Legal Limit
Write a dispute letter that specifically points out the legal cap. For example:
"The notice requests $[amount]. However, under Florida Statute 720.305(2), individual fines for a single violation are capped at $100. The excess amount of $[amount] is not legally collectible and I formally dispute that portion of the notice."
This is factual, calm, and legally accurate. Send it by certified mail. See our guide on how to send certified mail to your HOA.
For additional options on dealing with large fines without a lawyer, see our guide on cheap alternatives to HOA lawyers for fines under $1,000.
Find Out Exactly What Your HOA Can Charge
HOA Hound checks your fine against your state's caps, your HOA's published fine schedule, and the procedural steps they were required to follow. Know the number you actually owe — if anything.
Get your Protection Plan